What is Alternate State Testing?

As a parent or teacher of a student with special needs, navigating the world of standardized testing can be confusing and overwhelming. You may have heard about Alternate State Testing and wondered what it is, how it works, and whether it applies to your child or student. In this post, we’ll break it down in a clear and supportive way so you can make informed decisions and feel empowered.

Understanding Alternate State Testing

Alternate State Testing—also called Alternate Assessments—is a type of testing designed to allow students who are unable to participate in the general state assessments (even with accommodations) to demonstrate their knowledge and skills in a way that’s more accessible and appropriate for their unique needs.

Each state is required by federal law to administer statewide assessments in subjects like math, reading, and science. However, under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), states must also offer alternate assessments aligned with alternate academic achievement standards (AA-AAS) for students with significant disabilities.

The key purpose of alternate state testing is to ensure that all students are included in accountability systems and have the opportunity to show their progress—even if their learning path looks different from the typical student.

How Does a Student Qualify for Alternate Assessments?

Alternate assessments are not for every student with an Individualized Education Program (IEP). In fact, only about 1% of the total student population qualifies to take alternate assessments.

To determine eligibility, the IEP team—which includes the parent or guardian—must consider specific criteria. While each state may have slightly different guidelines, the general qualifications include:

• The student has a significant cognitive disability
• The student requires extensive, direct individualized instruction and substantial supports to achieve measurable gains
• The student is learning content aligned to alternate academic achievement standards, not the general education standards
• The student’s disability impacts multiple domains, including communication, adaptive behavior, and academic learning

It’s important to note that eligibility is not based on a specific disability label, IQ score, or classroom placement. Rather, it’s based on the student’s educational needs and the nature and severity of their disability.

The IEP team must document their decision, including the reasoning behind it, and ensure it is reviewed and updated at least annually.

Does IDEA Provide a Checklist?

While IDEA does not provide a strict checklist for alternate state testing eligibility, it does outline the requirements for determining participation in state and district-wide assessments. It’s up to each state to develop participation guidelines and decision-making tools for IEP teams.

Many states have created their own checklists or worksheets to help guide the conversation. These tools usually ask the team to reflect on factors such as:

• Whether the student is receiving instruction based on alternate academic achievement standards
• Whether the student requires extensive supports across settings
• Whether the student has a significant cognitive disability that affects their ability to participate in general assessments

It’s always a good idea to request your state’s specific guidelines from your school district or state Department of Education. These documents can help the IEP team make a clear, compliant decision.

Can a Parent Opt Their Child Out of State Testing?

This is a tricky and often misunderstood area.

Technically, federal law requires that all students—regardless of disability—participate in statewide assessments. This includes either the general assessment (with or without accommodations) or an alternate assessment for eligible students.

However, some states allow families to opt out of state testing, but those policies vary widely. In many states, opting out is not an option for students with disabilities unless there is a medical exemption or extraordinary circumstance.

If a parent strongly disagrees with their child’s participation in state assessments, it’s crucial to:

1. Have a conversation with the IEP team – Express concerns and explore appropriate assessment options.
2. Check your state’s policies – Some states require written requests or documentation to consider opt-out requests.
3. Understand the implications – Opting out could affect the school’s accountability reporting and may impact services or progress monitoring tools used in the IEP.

It’s worth noting that IEP teams cannot “opt-out” of testing on behalf of the parent. The team may determine whether the student qualifies for alternate assessments, but parents alone cannot unilaterally remove their child from state testing unless the state permits opt-outs and the necessary steps are taken.

Why This Matters

Alternate state testing ensures that students with the most significant disabilities are seen, counted, and supported. When used correctly, alternate assessments provide a meaningful way to monitor progress, adjust instruction, and celebrate student growth.

However, these decisions are deeply personal and require careful thought from the entire IEP team. Whether you’re a parent or an educator, your voice matters in making sure that the chosen path aligns with the student’s unique strengths and needs.

Understanding the Qualifications

Alternate state testing is not a “one-size-fits-all” solution—it’s a carefully designed option for students whose disabilities profoundly affect their ability to participate in general education assessments. It’s not simply that a child hasn’t had enough practice or preparation for a test; it’s much deeper. Understanding the qualifications, knowing your rights, and working collaboratively with the IEP team can make a big difference in the experience for both students and families.

If you have questions, don’t hesitate to ask for clarification from your child’s school or your district’s special education department. You’re not alone in this journey, and there are resources and people ready to help you navigate it.

Reference Information

IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act)

While IDEA doesn’t go into deep specifics about alternate assessments, it does establish that all students with disabilities must be included in state and district-wide assessments and that IEP teams must determine how a child will participate.

Relevant citations:

• 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(16)(A)
• All children with disabilities are included in all general State and district-wide assessment programs… with appropriate accommodations and alternate assessments where necessary and as indicated in their respective individualized education programs.
• 34 C.F.R. § 300.160
• This regulation provides more detailed requirements for participation in assessments and development of alternate assessments aligned with alternate academic achievement standards.

ESSA (Every Student Succeeds Act) – 2015

ESSA is where the federal rules for alternate assessments really get detailed. It limits the number of students who can participate in alternate assessments to no more than 1% of all students in a given subject statewide.

Relevant citations:

• 20 U.S.C. § 6311(b)(2)(D)
• States must provide for the participation in assessments of all students, including students with disabilities, and must develop alternate assessments aligned with alternate academic achievement standards for students with the most significant cognitive disabilities.
• 34 C.F.R. § 200.6(c) and (d)
• These sections of the Code of Federal Regulations outline requirements for alternate assessments, participation criteria, and the 1% cap on participation at the state level.

Note: ESSA doesn’t allow districts to set limits on how many students can take alternate assessments—it applies that 1% cap at the state level. States can request a waiver if they exceed the cap but must provide justification.

Writing IEPs doesn’t have to be overwhelming! The Intentional IEP gives you the tools, training, and resources to turn IEP chaos into clarity. With access to 10,000+ data-backed, standards-aligned goals, expert-led trainings, and ready-to-use data collection tools, you’ll save time, reduce stress, and feel confident in every IEP you write. Join today and transform your IEP process!